Ed Offer
Tuesday 16 May 2006
Spent the morning at Musselburgh discussion Teaching and Learning with fellow Primary and Secondary probationers in East Lothian. As Don has mentioned in his Blog of the session, the small group discussion was really interesting but was cut short to make time for the whole group-discussion.
Our group came up with some really good issues, particularly facing P7 to S1 transistion.
We agreed that teachers at S1 needed better knowledge of what topics and what type of activities Primary pupils had been doing prior to the August start-date. This has to be carefully collated so as not to damage the level of autonomy over lessons rightly enjoyed by Primary teachers, but it would enable secondary teachers to stretch students at S1.
A case in point: I’ve just got back course evaluation forms from our current S1 cohort and many of them have stated that they found certain bits ‘ boring’ because they had already covered them at Primary. The problem for us is that only some of our feeder primaries have covered these topics so they have to get taught at S1.
Don put forward the idea that Secondary should become more like Primary school. The initial reaction of most secondary teachers on Thursday was – what about my subject? I myself feel that my subject could come under threat if a primary approach is taken. Not enough History is taught in schools as it is, and there is a danger that the subject is consumed by more topic-led projects.
Nevertheless, the challenge for secondary teachers is to understand Primary teaching and take best practice from it. The emphasis on individuals having responsibility for their own learning pace and level is certainly something which can be forgotten in secondary, as there the emphasis is on covering the curriculum in hour lesson chunks.
Will look forward to reading the feedback from the session.
Lots to think about – anyone got any other comments/ideas?